A shoutout to all budding amateur sleuths, I need your help. I can't tell for sure, but there seems to be a correlation between the physical location of the mine shaft Ray was found murdered within, and the "1ST HOLE" denoted on the mudmap produced in the planning of their fateful prospecting trip.
If you haven't read the details of how and when the mudmap was produced, please read the previous Man in the HOLE post, Events Leading Up To 22nd March 2015, and/or sections of the Inquest Findings: 51 & 551.
To assist with your help in this investigation, I have created a basic map on Google Satellite Maps, linked here: Bell Chambers Map
The map includes:
One short section of the 230km long (143 miles) Paynes Find to Sandstone gravel "shortcut" shown in black line.
Bush tracks commonly used by prospectors, in orange lines.
Green pin indicating Ray & Jennie's camp location.
Red pin indicating the mine shaft where Ray was found.
Here’s a screenshot of it, if you don’t trust links.
And here is a copy of the mud map again, to jog your memory.
And here, I have transposed some of the symbols and distances noted by Ray, Jennie, and “Miller” (name changed) from the mudmap onto the satellite map image, as a suggestion that there may be a possible correlation.
Hmmmm… Dunno though, what do you guys reckon? Purely coincidental?
Obviously, the reason this might be important is because Ray was found down that mine shaft without any ropes, abseiling gear, nor even a shirt. The mine shaft that seems within the circle denoted “1ST HOLE” on their mudmap.
And there are reams of evidence that suggest the prospecting trio’s primary objective was to abseil into mineshafts, down HOLEs, to find gold.
Abseiling down mine shafts is very, very uncommon, dontcha know. If you’ve ever stood beside one of those mine shafts up Sandstone way you’d immediately understand why. Rickety centuries-old timber is all that’s between you and the walls collapsing in and burying your stupid corpse for daring be so moronic that you’d lower your idiotic self down the hole — the main reason why it is such an uncommon practice.
The stats are inconclusive, but I’d bet for sure that the total number of abseiling prospectors counted in Western Australia this past half-a-century is THREE. Three total that identified as abseiling prospectors, that is; and TWO that have actually done it. And ONE of those two is DEAD.
The DPP didn’t seem to think all this meant much when the Police wanted to charge someone for Ray and Jennie’s murder back in 2018.
But then, the State Coroner (God I love her) went and got old mate Professor R. Zellweger, Perth’s most notable orthopedic consultant, to do an independent report on Ray’s skeletal injuries — remember? Old mate Professor Zellweger compiled all the forensic specialist’ reports and went, “Nah mate, Ray didn’t fall down that shaft. No way, Jose. Not a chance, Lance!”
In other words, Ray must have somehow got himself down that twelve metre deep mine shaft, then someone must have come along and inflicted some pretty serious "high energy”, “high violence" trauma upon his bonce, then removed all the ropes and gear that they used to get down the shaft. At the bottom of a twelve-metre deep HOLE in a remote outback location! - can you believe it?
I mean, what are the odds? An actual plan to abseil down the very HOLE Ray was found within, Jennie never found yet declared to be deceased beyond doubt by the State Coroner, and someone still hasn’t been charged with any crimes!
Crazy stuff, huh. I just can’t work out what the ambiguity is. Maybe I’m naïve, or maybe I’m not — I’m sure it’s one of those.
So please, someone out there — any budding sleuths — please tell me what I am missing? Please explain to me why this is still not before the Criminal Court?
I reckon that the suspect, pushed Ray down the shaft, then went to get Jennie for help, stating he had accidentally fallen in. So he abseiled down the shaft with Jennie up top for support ( therefore cigarette buts) once down found he was still alive so he strangled him and dragged the body out of sight. After he came out I'm sure something happened between him and Jennie and he has disposed if her body in another mine shaft. Now my husbands theory as to which one and why.
.....
Black Range West 3 is a 'shut' mineshaft on the opposite side of Paynes Find-Sandstone Rd. (I am only looking at that shaft on Trilobite so I don't know if it is 'open'). But it would make sense to chose a shaft on the opposite side of the road, out of the search area. That particular shaft is easily accessed by a vehicle on a good track. Hence, no need to carry a body if you can drive right up to it. The fact that he didn't get mobile until 2am means he could have spent some time throwing dirt down the shaft to hide body and evidence.
I found it interesting that in tonight's episode of spotlight on 7 , the main suspect mentions seeing a car at the top of the hill and I think he said it was a prado???? And now he's driving one himself??? I mean most people have a dream or an idea of a car they'd love to own one day and why wouldn't he name a make of a car he doesn't own but wants to one day.
As for the cigarettes, my thought is Jennie was waiting at the top of the shaft for her husband to let her know it was safe for her to climb down or for him to return to the top. Instead the suspect had knocked her husband unconscious, killed him and came out to Jennie saying he's died and also had this crazy idea he and Jennie could now be together. She ran off to get help after rejecting him , he chased her down and killed her because she is the only one who can tell the real story.